by Louisa Hackett - Recently, a few community-based organizations, evaluators and funders gathered at the City University of New York Graduate Center to discuss, as one participant described it, the accountability regime eating us. Read more >>
News & Views
A blog for those interested in what affects, motivates and drives the New York City Nonprofit Sector — written by CRE’s crackerjack consulting team. We hope you use this space to share your thoughts, ask questions and engage in conversations about our city, social justice and the nonprofit sector.
Is Evaluation an Infection?
1
Find us on:
Tags
record keeping Data accountability Needs Assessment media computers CRE News Albany tips website, resources, announcements NYS Budget Neighborhood Based Capacity Building Initiative HIV/AIDS services providers nonprofit start-ups Jean Lobell Fran Barrett hard times Philanthropic Collaborative Valyrie Laedlein New York Times Bill Ryan RFP Ximena Rua-Merkin leadership Board of Directors National and Community Service executive transition handling the unexpected proposal writing Jeff Ballow announcment guest blogger Louisa Hackett CRE Tips Fran's Corner Nonprofit Quarterly grantmakers for effective organizations Alliance for Nonprofit Management Daring to Lead NYCCCOC Michael Hickey Peter Block nonprofit management evaluation internal controls generative Funding Updates What is Core? capacity building nonprofit accountability CRE Executive Search Nonprofit Tools CRE POV HR Without HR board leadership staff grantmakers Governance as Leadership Coaching Stanford Social Innovation Review postponed event New York Community Trust 30th Anniversary Nonprofit Sustainability lower Manhattan cre Mark Light government Client News Harvard Kennedy School Advocacy Useful Links nonprofit leaders Pavitra Menon fundraising nonprofit ownership Featured Items National Committee of Responsive Philanthropy board and staff relations harvard business school Beth Kobliner collaborations community bookkeeping IT Sector Research New York City Government Ero Gray strategic alliances mergers Holly Delany Cole MAC AIDS Fund President Obama Barbara Blumenthal Government News Mohan Sikka foundations New York executive Nonprofit News nonprofit mergers I.T. without I.T. arts Randall Quan Huffington Post case statement Nonprofit publications Government Updates queens jobs rockaways Rona Taylor Data Starved House Party
Subscribe via RSS feed
Comments
Allison
For the past few years, I've been trying to get nonprofits and funders to understand the difference between the terms accountability and evaluation. Accountability is basically the process of determinig if a nonprofit is behaving properly - are they spending money responsibly, are they providing the services they proposed, and are they serving the individuals they are supposed to.
Evaluation is really the process of determining what outcomes resulted from a program, sevice, and project, as well as determining what components lead to these outcomes. In it's most useful sense, this evaluation data would then be used to inform the next evolution of the program, sevice, or project.
Unfortunately, both funders and nonprofits have been stuck in thinking of only accountability. Blame falls on both sides.
Funders assume most nonprofits aren't sophisticated to do evaluation, and the funders rarely provide the additional funds necessary to do evaluation. Therefore, only accountability measures are requested as part of a reporting process.
Nonprofits also fail to stand up to funders and request additional funds for evaluation. Nonprofits too often fall into thinking that they can't question the funder, which leads to just doing the bare minimum that the funder wants, even if that limits the amount of knowledge the nonprofit could generate from doing evaluation (and not just accountability).
As for your idea that nonprofits need to redefine programs, Here Here!! See similar musing "Hope, dignity and quality of life are also valuable outcomes, even when measured in hours." at http://bit.ly/8iYuEk Gayle